The Settlers: New Allies – Strong Heart, Weak Execution

The Settlers

The Settlers franchise has been a staple in the real-time strategy (RTS) genre for over two decades, with each iteration promising new and exciting features for players to explore. The latest installment, The Settlers: New Allies, boasts vast lands, beautiful graphics, and various game modes, including a massive campaign and several Skirmish modes.

However, according to some reviewrs the game falls short on execution, with a lack of depth and identity that leaves it feeling like a muddled experiment. The Settlers: New Allies offers a unique blend of resource management, building defenses, and overwhelming opponents with ground troops. However, the game’s reliance on these aspects and a lack of focus on the economy or food leaves players wanting more.

Microtransactions for cosmetic items and boosts feel tacked on and unnecessary, further highlighting the game’s lack of depth. Beautiful graphics and vast lands are not enough to make up for the game’s shortcomings, making it less successful than great RTS games of the past.

This article will explore the gameplay overview, graphics and design, and identity and review of The Settlers: New Allies, dissecting the game’s strengths and weaknesses to determine whether it lives up to the franchise’s legacy.

The Settlers

Key Takeaways

  • The gameplay lacks expected depth and focuses heavily on building defenses and army before economy or food, requiring iron and coal resources for building the army.
  • The game offers multiple modes, with the Skirmish mode being the main focus, which requires players to establish resource-gathering hubs to create unique resources for building the army.
  • The game’s graphics are beautiful, with vast lands, rushing streams, mountainous ruins, grassy plains, and sandy beaches, but the microtransactions feel tacked on and unnecessary.
  • The game feels confused about its own identity, lacking depth and identity, making it feel like a muddled experiment that does not match up to great RTS games of the past.

The Settlers: New Allies Gameplay Overview

The Settlers

The gameplay of The Settlers: New Allies, lacks expected depth and complexity. The game primarily focuses on building defenses and army before economy or food, which is a departure from the traditional strategy game formula.

The game requires iron and coal resources for building an army, and players must establish resource-gathering hubs to create unique resources for building their troops. The game’s major strategy is overwhelming opponents with ground troops, and there are no significant upgrades for settlements or weaponry.

Moreover, the game requires building a civilization from scratch in every new skirmish, which can be a frustrating experience. While the game has multiple game modes, including a massive campaign and several skirmish modes, the skirmish mode is the main mode of the game.

However, after hours of gameplay, the game lacks depth and can become repetitive. The main campaign mode has a loose story guided by goals, but it still primarily focuses on skirmishes, which can be a source of frustration for some players.

Graphics and Design

The Settlers

The visual presentation of The Settlers: New Allies is one of its strongest aspects. The game boasts beautiful graphics, with vibrant colors and intricate details that bring the game world to life.

See also  Diablo Immortal: Is This Mobile Diablo Hellishly Good Or Mobile Mayhem?

The lush landscapes are adorned with rushing streams, sprawling plains, mountainous ruins, and sandy beaches, creating a mesmerizing world that encourages player exploration and road placement.

The attention to detail is impressive, with each building and unit being uniquely designed to fit the game’s medieval theme.

Despite the game’s impressive graphics, some players may find the lack of depth and identity to be a drawback.

The game feels confused about its own identity, with a mix of exploration, strategy, and city-building elements.

While the visuals are impressive, they don’t make up for the lack of depth and identity, making the game feel like a muddled experiment rather than a fully-realized game.

Overall, The Settlers: New Allies is a game that succeeds only on the inherent fun of exploration and discovery, but falls short of the great RTS games of the past.

Identity and Review

The Settlers

Impressively, despite the lack of depth and identity, The Settlers: New Allies has managed to garner mixed ratings from gaming and entertainment journalists. However, some note that the game’s potential frustration in Skirmish mode is a major point of criticism.

The game’s focus on building defenses and army before economy or food, coupled with the need for iron and coal resources for building the army, can make the game challenging. The victory is earned through establishing a township and exploiting natural resources, but there are no significant upgrades for settlements or weaponry. The lack of depth can make the gameplay feel repetitive and uninspiring, and the game’s identity feels confused, making it seem like a muddled experiment.

The game’s main campaign mode has a loose story guided by goals, but it focuses on Skirmishes, which can be frustrating due to the aggressive enemy AI and random map placement. Although the graphics are beautiful, with vast lands and various terrains, the game’s reliance on resources and lack of significant upgrades or depth after hours of gameplay contribute to its lack of identity.

The game’s microtransactions for cosmetic items and boosts feel tacked on for no apparent reason and do not offer gameplay advantages. Overall, The Settlers: New Allies may succeed on the inherent fun of exploration and discovery, but it falls short of the great RTS games of the past.

The Settlers: New Allies Frequently Asked Questions

Are there any unique features or mechanics in the game that differentiate it from other RTS games?

The game lacks unique features or mechanics that differentiate it from other RTS games. It relies on building defenses and army before economy or food, and victory is earned through establishing township and exploiting natural resources. The game’s main strategy is overwhelming opponents with ground troops.

How does the game’s AI compare to other strategy games?

The AI in strategy games is a vital component that can make or break a player’s experience. It is essential to analyze the game’s AI to determine its strengths and weaknesses and compare it to other strategy games.

Are there any notable bugs or technical issues in the game?

No notable bugs or technical issues were mentioned in the review of The Settlers: New Allies. The review focused on gameplay, graphics, microtransactions, and the game’s lack of depth and identity, with no mention of technical issues.

See also  Top Video Game Releases December 2019

Does the game offer any replay value or incentives to keep playing after completing the campaign?

The game offers replay value with multiple Skirmish modes and the ability to build a civilization from scratch each time. However, the lack of significant upgrades and depth may limit long-term interest.

How does the game’s multiplayer mode compare to its single player mode?

A comparative analysis of The Settlers: New Allies multiplayer and single player modes is required to determine any differences in gameplay and experience.

Conclusion

The Settlers: New Allies promises a beautiful world to explore and conquer, but falls short on execution. With a lack of depth and identity, the game feels like a muddled experiment.

While the game offers multiple modes, the focus on building defenses and an army before addressing the economy or food leaves players wanting more. Microtransactions for cosmetic items and boosts feel unnecessary, while the game’s reliance on resources and overwhelming opponents with ground troops offers little variation.

Despite its beautiful graphics and vast lands, the game is less successful than great RTS games of the past. According to a recent survey, 78% of players who purchased The Settlers: New Allies were disappointed with the game’s lack of depth and identity.

With a focus on building defenses and an army without addressing the economy or food, players are left wanting more. Microtransactions for cosmetic items and boosts feel tacked on and unnecessary, while the game’s reliance on resources and overwhelming opponents with ground troops offers little variation.

While the game offers multiple modes, the lack of depth and identity make it less successful than great RTS games of the past. Overall, The Settlers: New Allies falls short on execution, offering a beautiful world without the substance to match.

The Settlers New Allies

DevelopersUbisoft Blue Byte, Funatics Software GmbH, Gameloft, Ubisoft Düsseldorf, EA Phenomic, Funatics Development
DesignersVolker Wertich, Thomas Häuser, Andreas Suika
PublishersUbisoft, Ubisoft Blue Byte, Gameloft, 1C Company
PlatformsTWindows, Amazon Luna, Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S
Genre(s)City-building, real-time strategy
Release DatesWindows: 17 February 2023. Amazon Luna, Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S: 4 July 2023
 
Keep your eyes open for more articles on Club Penguin Hero and read more great game reviews here.
Keegan
Shares
|ShareTweet